There are more baby products on the market today than ever. This is even true of baby carriers.
Now you can select the baby carrier that is best for your needs. Padded shoulder straps, hip carry options, adjustable head support, an infant insert, and adjustable heights are some of the things you can have when selecting a baby carrier.
In this article, we’ll compare two of the best-reviewed, better-known baby carriers on the market: Ergobaby vs Baby Bjorn.
These two heavy hitter companies offer baby carriers sure to have all the bells and whistles you need to have met when it comes to comfortable baby wearing.
We shall compare both brands using the following criteria:
- Age range and weight limits
- Carrying positions
- Sun protection
Baby Bjorn Baby Carrier
Baby Bjorn is a Swedish company that has been around since the early 1960s. They make many products for babies and toddlers, but they are best known for their baby carrier.
Regarded by millions of parents to be top of the line in terms of comfort and reliability, Baby Bjorn baby carriers have relied heavily on the success of this product to keep the company and all of its products at the forefront of the minds of parents when considering baby products.
Age range and weight Limits
Parents want products that will grow with their babies. Many baby carriers are either not suited for very young babies or newborn babies or require the additional purchase of an infant insert to carry smaller babies.
The Baby Bjorn carrier, however, requires no additional purchase or separate infant insert.
Children from newborn to about three years of age can use the Baby Björn baby carrier easily and comfortably. So for many parents, the first Baby Bjorn carrier they purchase is also the last and best baby carrier for them for this reason alone.
Both you and your little one can stay comfortable through the toddler years using just one device.
Gone are the days when the only carry positions you could choose from for a baby carrier were either front carry or back carry position. With the Baby Bjorn, you get four carry positions to choose from.
There is newborn, inward facing, outward facing, and back carry. While this seems pretty standard, it wasn’t always an option for parents even a generation ago.
One of the reasons that Ergobaby got started was because of a lack of comfort and back support from other carriers.
Therefore, it’s no big surprise that Baby Bjorn falls short regarding lumbar support and padded shoulder straps that can ease back and shoulder pain.
While some people don’t seem to mind it and find the Baby Bjorn perfectly comfortable, most people who have used one wouldn’t rate this as the best baby carrier for comfort or back support.
Regarding protection from the sun or privacy, the Baby Bjorn leaves something to be desired. When it comes to Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby, this is another category in that Ergo Baby has a leg up.
Not only have parents been somewhat unhappy that there’s no baby hood or privacy hood attached to keep baby cool in the sunlight and heat, but it’s also complicated to breastfeed while wearing this baby gear.
This can make for quite a fussy baby when trying to avoid the sun’s harsh rays or when your breastfeeding babe is hungry.
Ergobaby Baby Carrier
The Ergobaby company has been around since 2003. It all came into being when a mom in Hawaii didn’t like her baby carrier and wanted more options.
Although they are somewhat new to the scene, they quickly rose in stature and are now major competitors of Baby Bjorn.
Age and weight Limits
When comparing the Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby carriers based upon what age and weight child can fit in them comfortably, there’s not a clear winner.
While the Baby Bjorn can hold a newborn without needing an infant insert, it can only carry a child up until age 3. Ergobaby requires the additional purchase of an infant insert for a child who weighs between seven and twelve pounds.
While this is undoubtedly a bit of a bummer, they make up for it by the longevity of the carrier.
The Ergobaby carrier can be used until a child reaches age 4, or 48 pounds. This means it’s not usable for about the first four months of life without an insert, but it can be used years longer than the Baby Bjorn.
Like the Baby Bjorn, the Ergobaby allows for four carrying positions. However, they are not the same positions and offer more variety.
With the Ergobaby carrier, you can choose inward facing, outward facing, back carry, or hip carry.
Being able to hip-carry your child is perfect for older babies and frees up your arms. This is a significant perk for many parents.
With its padded shoulder straps and built-in lumbar support, the Ergobaby is comfortable for both the wearer and the baby. This added support allows you to carry and distribute the baby’s weight evenly, keeping you from getting sore unnecessarily.
Ergo baby keeps the wearer in mind while thinking of the baby at the same time.
This is the one baby carrier that keeps people with back problems, shoulder issues, and other such issues in mind. No one wants to carry a baby around all day and feel it broke their back. However, it’s not without its qualms from some.
Because of the waist belt, some taller moms and dads have complained that the carrier is not adjustable enough to keep from rubbing or digging into their backs when wearing the Ergobaby.
If you are a tall person, this may not be a suitable carrier for you. Consider trying it on before purchasing it if offered the chance.
Protection from the sun
Ergo baby has a privacy hood that can help your baby escape the sun’s harmful rays and is a great baby hood to use for privacy with breastfeeding.
It’s also great for a sleeping baby when you go from a dark area into a more well-lit area.
The best of both worlds
The Baby Björn carrier and the Ergobaby carrier may have their differences, but there are some things that both of these companies have in common, which may help you in your decision.
It’s always good to know that no matter your choice, you’ll get some of the same perks. The following are some things that the Baby Bjorn carrier and the Ergobaby have in common.
Both are a hip-healthy carrier
Both carriers get the thumbs up from the International Hip Dysplasia Institute.
Babies are more flexible because their muscles are not fully formed, their bones are still somewhat soft, and many of them have not yet connected and fused.
If you consider the position of most babies in the womb, the baby’s hips are not spread the way they almost have to be in a carrier. Because of this, prolonged exposure to a carrier or spending many hours at a time in one can dislocate the hips or cause dysplasia.
So even though active parents may be getting out and about with their baby, which is good, prolonged use of a carrier can still cause hip dysplasia in their babies, regardless of what type of carrier you use.
Padding and fit
Most parents prefer one carrier to another, but both options in this article offer benefits to give the proper support, regardless of body type or size of the parent wearing it.
Both of the carriers are of mesh material, which means that they allow airflow. This is good because you can still keep the baby comfortable, even in warm weather, because of that breathable and light material.
This is also great because as the baby grows and things become snugger in the carrier, you need a light material.
The Ergobaby carrier does have clip-in buckles, which tends to divide consumers because it is difficult for some to get the back buckles clipped. Others love it for its stability.
Having your baby in the correct position is vital for safety reasons, as well as comfort.
You don’t want to have your baby too far up in the carrier when forward facing, for example, and have the baby dangling out of the carrier, risking a nasty fall. This is where height settings come in.
Both of the carriers offer height settings that you can set (two of them) for your growing baby, whether they are forward-facing or facing backward.
The difference lies in where that feature is.
The Baby Bjorn has the seat adjuster inside the carrier, making it fairly easy to get to and tweak to fit your baby better. The Ergobaby, on the other hand, has a button that has to be depressed from the outside of the carrier.
For a lot of moms and dads, this gives the Baby Bjorn a slight edge, but there are plenty of parents who don’t mind the way they have to adjust the Ergobaby.
Babies are messy. They drool, spit, eat like they can’t find their mouths sometimes, and touch everything.
Lucky for the consumer, both carriers discussed in this article are machine wash friendly. The Baby Bjorn has long been praised for how well it retains its shape after a wash.
Just be sure that you don’t use fabric softener. A fabric softener works by depositing a waxy film on clothes, making materials feel softer.
First of all, neither carrier needs help in the softness department. Secondly, fabric softener risks clogging up the holes in the mesh, making it less breathable, and possibly overheating your little one.
Price and availability information
Unfortunately, neither of these baby carriers is very affordable.
If you look at your baby carrier as an investment that you will get to reap the benefits of for a few years, and you know that you will use it frequently, then you can justify that it’s worth the money.
For example, the Babybjörn One Air, when viewed online at a relevant Amazon site, costs a little over $200. It is arguably the company’s most popular model.
The Ergobaby Omni 360 is around $175, depending on where you look online and what discounts you can find.
If you want either the Ergobaby Omni 360 or the Baby Bjorn One Air, you may be able to find it on sale online.
Just be warned that when they go on sale, they sell quickly. Be sure to check the availability information displayed on the site you’re considering so that you don’t miss out.
Ergobaby vs Baby Bjorn: The Final Verdict
Various carriers boast that they offer the best luxury, safety, and ease of use.
However, the Ergobaby Omni 360 and the Baby Bjorn One Air are the best on the market. You can’t go wrong when it comes to Ergobaby Omni 360 vs Baby Bjorn One Air.
You must do your homework, read many reviews, and consider your unique situation, build, and baby before buying any baby product, whether for personal use or as a baby shower gift.
The important thing is that you keep safety in mind whatever choice you make. Never use any baby carrier for long periods of time, as your child can end up with hip problems, pain, discomfort, or overheating.
Be sure to consider your body type and whether you need to breastfeed or provide shade to your baby. Knowing precisely what you want and need will help make your decision easier.