Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby—Types of Pacifiers & FAQs

Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby

Breastfed babies have a powerful suckling reflex, and finding suitable pacifiers for breastfed babies can be a huge chore. There is a huge selection of different types, brands, and styles of pacifiers, each of them claiming to be better than the next.

This article will help you understand your options when it comes to pacifiers for breastfed babies so you can steer clear of things like nipple confusion for your newborn baby. We will also list the best pacifier for breastfed baby, so that you can make the best choice possible when it comes to your baby.

Newborn Babies and Pacifiers

You have probably heard people of older generations caution against pacifiers, especially for breastfed babies.

The thought process behind this is that pacifiers are habit-forming and that using one will cause issues with the baby’s mouth, such as buck teeth and cavities.

In breastfed babies, the idea is that it can cause nipple confusion so that breastfed babies refuse to latch onto the breast and instead demand the pacifier.

Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and Pacifiers

Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) is a fatal occurrence that happens to babies, usually under the age of twelve months.

Safe sleep guidelines have been developed to prevent injury and death of infants, especially those with SIDS. One of those pieces of information that doctors and researchers say will help safeguard your little one is the use of a pacifier at night.

Sucking on a pacifier while sleeping forces a baby’s mouth to open slightly, and the tongue thrusts forward. This prevents the tongue from blocking the airway.

In many studies, infants, breastfeeding babies, and formula-fed babies alike had less risk of SIDS when using a pacifier.

Types of Pacifiers

When you walk into a store and get to the aisle with the pacifiers, you will likely find yourself more than a little overwhelmed. Having a firm grasp of understanding the different types of pacifiers will help you decide.

Orthodontic Pacifier

An orthodontic pacifier has what looks like an odd shape to the nipple. It is flat at the bottom. This type of pacifier is beneficial to the baby’s mouth as it reduces the chance for the baby to have dental issues due to pacifier use.

Rounded Nipple Pacifiers

These pacifiers for breastfed babies are supposed to help prevent nipple confusion in the breastfed baby.

Nipple confusion occurs when a baby uses a pacifier and literally gets it confused with the mother’s nipple.

This confusion can result in a breastfed baby who refuses to latch onto the breast because they prefer the pacifier.

The rounded nipple shape of these pacifiers will help breastfed babies because they mimic the form of a human nipple.

The hope is that newborn babies and infants will not be able to distinguish the difference and, therefore, will not have any significant issues with latching or breastfeeding.

The Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Infants

If you are breastfeeding your infant or plan to, you want to be sure to select pacifiers that will benefit your baby and not lead to confusion. If you can also avoid any dental issues with orthodontic pacifiers, that is a plus.

The following are some of the top-rated and reviewed pacifiers for breastfed babies.

The First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers

Not only does this have a nipple that mimics the mom’s nipple, but there is also a cutout for the baby’s nose that will keep the airway from being blocked.

Be sure to select a pacifier that coincides with your child’s age, regardless of the type. For example, if you like this pacifier, and have a newborn, make sure you get only the newborn size.

Otherwise, the Gumdrop pacifier will be too large and will cover the baby’s nose, which could be dangerous.

It also comes in cute designs and can be used in conjunction with a pacifier clip so that you are not searching for it every day.

Pacifier clips are great, but remember not to attach one to the baby at night in the crib, as it can quickly become a strangulation risk.

Nuk Orthodontic Pacifier

If you are looking for orthodontic pacifiers that are also great for breastfeeding, this is one of the best pacifiers on the market.

A silicone pacifier with a scoop-shaped nipple cavity—is resilient against tears and will help your fussy baby calm down between feedings without creating confusion.

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

This is one of the best pacifiers, and once you get a look at it, you will likely recognize it right away.

This is often your baby’s pacifier right after birth because it is known to be one of the best pacifiers, particularly for newborns. Many hospitals choose this brand and style in the nursery ward.

An all-silicone pacifier made with medical-grade silicone, this is a durable pacifier. It is also BPA-free.

Although it is pretty plain and only comes in a solid green color, it is one of the best pacifiers for tiny newborn babies.

Best pacifiers for breastfed baby

Chicco Naturalfit

With a cutout to enable better breathing, this pacifier is made entirely of silicone. It also comes with a silicone handle, which is a total gamechanger.

Nanobebe Baby Flexy

Fantastic for brand new babies, these pacifiers are very flexible and are easily manipulated by little fingers and gums. Made of silicone and safe for use, these are great for the breastfed newbie.


These pacifiers are firmly attached to plush toy animals that will give your little one some entertainment, a safe teething toy, and an easier way for parents to find it when dropped. Also perfect for nursing babies, these are a favorite for several reasons.

Brown’s HappyPaci

The shield makes all the difference when it comes to these pacifiers. Wholly made of silicone, these pacifiers have shields that face away from the face, guaranteeing that there will be no airflow obstruction and significantly reducing the risk of rash due to wetness.


This pacifier was made with soothing in mind. With a jewel-shaped nipple, this pacifier was designed by a dentist to help maintain oral health while also soothing an infant.

Nuk Airflow

With its heart-shaped shield, this pacifier offers three times more ventilation and airflow, meaning that the baby will rarely end up with a wet face after using it.


Available in many sizes, shapes, and designs, this company offers just about any pacifier you may need, including one for your breastfed baby. You can find anything you want in a pacifier with BIBS, from orthodontics to soothing, teething to glow in the dark.

Itzy Ritzy Soother

Voted the most durable by parents who have given them a try, these pacifiers can take a lot of abuse. They are ventilated and very thick and come in many colors with many designs. They are free of BPA and harmful chemicals and are great for breastfed babies.

MAM Pacifier

The MAM company makes some of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. With a nipple that simulates the mom’s nipple, this pacifier also features a cutout so that baby can breathe more easily.

They come in a variety of colors and designs and are adorable. Some are even glow-in-the-dark, so you can find them in the middle of the night as your little one spits them out of the crib.

MAM is a favorite for everything from pacifiers to baby bottles, which also come with nipples that mimic the breast.

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Nighttime Pacifier

This is one of the best baby pacifiers for several reasons. The silicone nipples are strong and durable. They also glow in the dark. They have an orthodontic nipple that is BPA-free and will not interfere with breastfeeding, and they are available in three different sizes.

Evenflo Feeding Balance Pacifier

This is one of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. These baby pacifiers are plain-looking but offer many perks. Do not pass it up just because it is not “cute.”

BPA-free, this silicone pacifier is a sheer and clear pacifier that has vents to keep baby’s face dry to prevent rashes and irritation associated with spit and wetness on the face. It is also cylinder-shaped, which benefits babies who breastfeed so as not to create confusion between the nipples.

The only real downside to these pacifiers is that they are difficult to find when dropped or lost in the dark due to their clear color. However, you can get clips and attachments to help with this problem, which we will also discuss.

Best orthodontic pacifier, Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby

Ali + Oli Modern Pacifier

This medical-grade silicone pacifier may be minimalist and somewhat plain-looking, but do not scoff. It may just be the right pacifier for your baby.

This is just about the safest pacifier on the market. It is BPA-free, so you do not have to worry about any harmful chemicals used to make the product. It also has a concave pacifier shield, which will not interfere with your child’s breathing.

Known as the best pacifier in terms of safety, it is also a great baby pacifier in terms of breastfeeding as it mimics the shape of a mom’s nipples. The company is so sure that you will love it that they offer a full refund when you return it within 10 days—no questions asked, 100% money-back guarantee.

Doddle and Co.’s Pop Silicone Pacifier

The best pacifier for the busy mom, these things do not even look like pacifiers at first glance. Brightly colored and oddly shaped, these pacifiers are designed to protect the pacifier nipple from disaster when the pacifier falls somewhere gross.

This baby pacifier pops itself from a straight pacifier to a capsule-like contraption when dropped, protecting the nipple from things like germs, the ground, the seat or floorboard of your car, the carpet, etc.

Philips Wee Thumbie

The best pacifier for premature babies, even tube-fed babies who need a bit of extra care. These are tiny pacifiers meant for low birth weight babies. Not intended for use by older babies, these cater to the little ones who are not big enough for a newborn pacifier.

Rather than simulating a mother’s nipple, the nipple of this pacifier is shaped and sized to mimic a baby’s thumb so that even babies fed through a tube can practice their sucking reflex. It also has a BPA-free silicone nipple to ensure safety from harsh or harmful chemicals.

Pacifiers for Teething Babies

Other pacifiers discussed so far were geared more towards little infants and new babies who are not yet dealing with things like teething. Baby’s teeth start to come in, and when that happens, they tend to chew on everything they can get in their mouths.

Healthy oral development is important, and choosing a durable pacifier that will not easily break or get chewed through is essential to eliminate a choking hazard.

Silicone pacifiers tend to be fairly durable, and while many of them are just thick silicone, there are plenty of silicone options that are cute pacifiers. Silicone nipples also help to combat the risk of any latex allergies a baby might have.

RazBaby Raz-Berry

This is a perfect pacifier for breastfed babies who are teething or fussy babies who are teething. Baby’s tongue will surprise you when you give this pacifier to your little one, who is starting to cut teeth.

This particular pacifier is larger than a normal one, and it has bumps like a raspberry. The bumps help soothe a baby’s gums when the teething process is in full swing.

Molar Muncher

This odd-looking, prolonged pacifier is designed to get to the molars in the back that traditional pacifiers just cannot reach.

Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Giraffe Attachment

A lightweight plush toy that can be attached to your pacifier, a teething baby, will love this. A welcome distraction from the annoyances and discomforts of teething, it also acts as a teether on its own.

It is also easier to find an entire plush animal attached to the pacifier when the baby drops it. A lost pacifier is a terrible experience. This product will help prevent that nightmare.

FAQ About Pacifiers

The following are some of the most frequently asked questions regarding pacifiers.

Aside from silicone, are there other safe materials?

Yes. Denmark designed and made Frigg Daisy is, a natural rubber pacifier that is safe from harmful substances and chemicals.

What is the difference between infant pacifiers and pacifiers for older babies?

Pacifier shapes, styles, and sizes all change as the baby outgrows one stage of the pacifier and moves to the next. The silicone or rubber is thicker, the shields are larger to safeguard bigger mouths, and there is more need for an orthodontic pacifier as children grow their teeth.

You can still find a pacifier for breastfed babies in these larger sizes.

What if I lose my baby’s pacifier? Can I use something else?

Only give your baby things that are meant to be chewed or sucked on. You might be tempted to simply use your Brown’s bottle nipple to soothe a crying baby, but these do not have sturdy enough shields and are not meant to be used as a pacifier.

It is suggested that you buy several pacifiers always to have a spare.

You might Also like...

Subscribe to
receive your FREE
"58 Newborn Essentials"
Registry Guide